- July 2016 Incident: Hig drilled a gap in an elevator room on the constructing’s roof, resulting in water intrusion from rain, inflicting intensive property injury.
- October 2016 Incident: A water tank change put in by Home failed, resulting in water leakage down 27 flooring, additional damaging the challenge.
Consigli had insurance coverage protection from a number of suppliers, together with Harleysville, Zurich American Insurance coverage Firm, Catlin Insurance coverage Firm, and Starr Indemnity & Legal responsibility Firm. Harleysville, which had been offering a protection for Consigli, sought a courtroom ruling that it had no additional obligation to defend or indemnify. Alternatively, it argued that if its protection remained in place, different insurers ought to share within the prices of defending Consigli.
